Tuesday, September 11, 2018
Thank you, Philip!
What a great piece by Philip Patston on the yestodignity website!
There's been quite a lot of talk from the nay-sayers that the Bill does not take enough account of people with disabilities.
Philip's testimony is concise and personal: "As a disabled person myself I want the choice, if I’m in unbearable pain or suffering in my life, to end it in a way and at the time that I choose. I think it’s really important my voice and the voice of other disabled people, who aren’t afraid of the End Of Life Choice Bill becoming legislation, are heard as much as people who are not as supportive of the Bill."
Philip says it all. Nobody can ask for more. Nobody should have to accept less.
We have to persuade our MPs that there is a clearly defined majority of the population who hope for something to come out of the tortuous process of legislative change to make choice possible for those who wish to have it.
Wednesday, September 5, 2018
More on the Orewa Meeting

Our other local paper, Hibiscus Matters, has printed a comprehensive write-up of the Orewa debate on the End of Life Choice Bill. It tells me there were 400 present, a lot more than I estimated.
It offers comments from a selection of audience members on both sides but also gave a lot of space to written quotes from myself (I didn't as much as ask a question on the night!), emphasising the usefulness of getting together and hearing others' views. It was not as pessimistic as my post of 22 August for which I am grateful. We need to keep having the debate, no matter how boring it may seem to those of us who've travelled with the issues for years.
However, the tally of only 200 votes handed in on the night is almost 50-50 on the main issue (Let's face it, the Bill would be lost on half a dozen of those votes!). But this informal tally of self-selected people cannot possibly be said to be representative of the Rodney electorate population at large. If our MP is thinking that will be good enough to "get the mind of the electorate" that would be a sad day for democracy.
Wednesday, August 29, 2018
A Moral Example?
Given these difficulties for the Roman Catholic community, how is it that their leaders in this country can feel they have the moral authority to project their theological and ethical views on the whole of society in another area of human behaviour?
- It is an open secret that Catholic parishioners were instructed by the Bishops to write to both the recent Parliamentary Committees hearing submissions on End of Life issues.
- It is also known that the bishops also urged their people not to admit to being Catholic because the Church's image in the community is not too hot (Now there's a funny thing....).
- And it is on the public record that the current Justice Committee received around 27,000 submissions that were not much more than a name and an address and a sentence such as "I am not in favour of the End of Life Choice Bill".
How can they make such a claim? Will Parliament go along with this astonishing analysis? I'm no statistical whiz but I know that you cannot draw conclusions about the wishes of any population from a self-selected group who may have an axe to grind and want to lay their views on everyone else.
The fact is that the population has spoken. Every professionally conducted poll in this country for decades has produced a majority of respondents in favour of some form of Medical Aid in Dying. The latest was around 76% in favour.
The proposed Bill is not perfect but it is a cautious step forward. Anyone who wants to express doubts about it should read the wording before commenting. And Parliament should get on with doing the best it can for the majority. All we ask for is the one thing conservative churchmen and others are at great pains to deny us: CHOICE.
Wednesday, August 22, 2018
Where Does Meaning Meet?
A packed hall in Orewa last night had a really
good airing of the issues around the End of Life Choice Bill. On a dirty evening there was an excellent turnout of locals - and probably a few carpet-baggers from adjacent electorates - and a top-line national panel of
speakers for and against. The audience gave them frequent but not especially enthusiastic
applause.
There were questions from the floor
for a full hour but, as with the panel speakers, no new ground was broken.
There are no new insights into the issue on either side.
I was reminded of the two housewives
(this story must have come from the 1950s!) who used to argue the big issues of
life across the fence between their two properties. They could never come to
any agreement on whatever they discussed because they were arguing from
different premisses.
That's the problem with the End of
Life Choice discussion. Both sides start from totally different understandings
of the meaning of life, death, compassion, and, especially, palliative care. Both even use language that is exclusive to their own side and not acceptable to the other.
It's great that there was such a good
audience last night. I hope that many of them came without the strong
prejudices held by some of us who have grappled with the issues for years.
Perhaps last night's newbies to the discussion can make more dispassionate
evaluation of the issues on both sides. If that is taking place around our
community, the meeting must be considered a great success.
Monday, August 13, 2018
Justice in the Justice Committee?
A few minutes ago, Dr Jack Havill, the former President of End-of-Life Choice, when making his submission to members of the Justice Committee at a Hearing in Hamilton added these extraordinary and unconventional comments:-
"The second part of this submission may seem very
unusual.
It is a complaint about the Deputy Chair of the Justice Select
Committee. I have spoken to many New Zealanders and they cannot understand why,
as the Deputy Chair of the Selection Committee, hearing oral submissions on the
(End of Life Choice) Bill, the Honourable Maggie Barry should show her bias so
publicly and indeed spend much of her time campaigning at public meetings
against medical aid in dying.
This seems to the average member of the public as totally unfair,
especially as she has also been aggressive to actual submitters while giving
(their) oral submission.
We do not maintain that she should not have opinions against the
Bill, but we expect her to act impartially in her role as Deputy Chair, and to
consider evidence which support MAID in a reasonable manner.
She has been bringing the process into dispute.
Our opinion is that she should resign from the position as Deputy
Chair because she is heavily compromised."
I have already indicated in
this blog that I was deeply concerned at Maggie Barry's attitude in the Hearing
which I attended on 29 June. From this brief experience, and seeing her
speaking publicly in opposition to the Bill I can only endorse Dr Havill's
concern.
I observed submitters in favour
of the Bill being subjected to aggressive questioning, to denials that their
submissions could be true, and to lectures on the other side of the issue. One
submitter was subjected to just plain rudeness while making a strongly felt
submission; she suddenly found that the Chair of the Day had left her seat
and walked some distance away to make herself a cup of tea.
I believe the Speaker of the
House has been approached about the apparent conflict of interest. I understand
he was given the astonishing reply that there is no Code of Conduct set
down for the conduct of Parliamentary Hearings. Members are not,
apparently, even expected to maintain a show of impartiality.
That is certainly how the Auckland Hearing was conducted on Friday 29 June.
I suggest that in the interest of the “fair play” that we in this
country pride ourselves upon that Ms Barry either immediately recuse herself as
a Hearer or else cease offering her opinions on any public stage.
She cannot have it both ways. She must choose. Either decision could
be a simple action that would restore some show of integrity to the Parliamentary
Select Committee on Justice.
And I hope that she makes this
choice before speaking against the Bill at a public meeting called by our MP
Mark Mitchell, to be held in Orewa on Tuesday 21st. I will be there and I hope
a good crowd of fair-minded locals will turn out – on both sides of the
argument – to engage together in a congenial and democratic process of
exploring the issues.
Monday, August 6, 2018
Ca Pros Update
It's been a fairly frenetic few weeks for this household, but the medical report is that the substantial pains emanating from the cancer in my spine in June have been abated by five targeted bursts of radiation. Apart from (almost inevitable) tummy upsets and some unrelated pain in my left ankle I've had a really good run in the last three or four weeks.
After all the stress of making a submission to the Parliamentary Select Committee on Justice I thought it would be easy enough to chat to the local reporter of the Rodney Times. But the whole of the front cover and two inside pages devoted to her report was a surprise. And to be told by someone I'd never met that the interview and a video involving both Bev and me had gone up on the national news carrier Stuff was much more of a surprise. Do look at it - it's Bev's first venture on public media. Both the video and the text have created a lot of interest just at the time our local MP is hosting a first public forum to debate the issues.
And guess what? The MP whose lack of impartiality I have roundly criticised is billed to speak against the Bill on which, as deputy Chair of the Parliamentary Select Committee on Justice, she is supposed to be conducting unbiased Hearings. I discussed this shameful conflict of interest with the reporter and it's going to be the subject of a further news release involving other people who were more affected than I was.
In the middle of all this stuff we've had some pleasant drives in the country and have had the Leaf's annual service for some 9000kms done for $54. And that's including a wheel rotation that I ordered. This particular EV is definitely not heavy on the family purse... and giving us a great deal of pleasure at a somewhat critical time in our lives.
Now Bev has reminded me about a bread mixture I put in the machine after breakfast and I have no idea when I started it... I'd better go and see what to make of it. It looks like this loaf may get a double rising... And as soon as that's done we're heading out for a drive for less than the cost of a cup of coffee. Of course, somewhere, we'll buy two coffees and share a piece of cake.
Sunday, July 29, 2018
Bev and I on the End-of-Life Choice Bill
A Waikanae lady I've never met has just
phoned to tell us how our piece this week had moved her to thank us and wish us
well. It was especially timely as we hadn't seen it ourselves after buying copies of the Sunday Star Times!
We were sensitively interviewed by
Juliet McGhie of the Rodney Times and Videographer Anna who must have shot 150
photos. Their story has been picked up by Stuff and can be seen at the link below.
We don't want to make a huge fuss but we
are willing to speak out on this issue which is becoming very personal and
relevant for us. But it's a little ironic that July has been so much better for me than
June.
And if I get invited to have a chat with
the Bishop, I'd be happy to fit it into the September trip to see all the
grand- and great-grand kids.
www.stuff.co.nz/national/health/105708352/former-methodist-ministers-desperate-support-for-the-end-of-life-choice-bill
Friday, July 20, 2018
Same old same old arguments...
As we continue in a prolonged period of waiting while the Justice Committee of Parliament hears all the same old arguments all over again, the following is a refreshing and hopeful statement.
“The laws that authorize medical aid in dying have worked exactly as intended, the evidence shows. They have benefited dying patients and their families without causing any harm to anyone.
“None of the problems that were expected by opponents have emerged. There is no
disproportionate effect on vulnerable populations, no evidence of a slippery slope.”
The writer was David C. Leven, executive director emeritus and a senior consultant to End of Life Choices New York, in a letter to the New York Times on June 20, words our MPs should bear in mind as they consider the Bill before Parliament.
This and other relevant matters are fully discussed in the current newsletter of the End-of-Life Choice Society. But also discussed are the tactics of some of the opposition such as Catholic Bishops who have "inspired fear and loathing with puerile lies that people with asthma, arthritis and gluten intolerance would be euthanized."
MP Maggie Barry is one who has swallowed this kind of line. At the recent E.O.L.C hearing I quoted the 75-85% of kiwis who supported some change in the law and she responded with a lecture on the unreliability of national polls because the pollsters could skew them to get the results they wanted. And what about the 3% or 4% margin of error? she said. My parting shot was that a margin of error of 20% would still leave a substantial majority in favour of change. And she is co-Chair of the Justice Committee hearing submissions. When prejudice and statistical ignorance enters this kind of discussion, truth is hard to establish.
Another point in the newsletter is that the likelihood of a majority of 61 being secured by March next year is by no means assured. An analysis of the current likely voting is very interesting, but worrying. The opposition has massive organisation and funding and can be expected to mount a major PR campaign before the Parliament actually votes.
All this lends weight to a point a made in my submission (see June 19), to the effect that the lack of this kind of law change is likely to result in my taking into my own hands what is necessary to deal with unbearable and untreatable pain.
Saturday, June 30, 2018
Moving along some more
We've now done the MRI which I believe showed nothing untoward in my right ear which went into low gear when we were on a cruise last January.
We have had a thoroughly pleasant interview with our Rad/Oncologist and we have agreed to go on a short course of radiation therapy, starting this coming week. If it's no worse than 2014, I guess I will cope with it OK.
But my tests this week aren't so great. My blood sugar is right up in the diabetic range and seems not to have responded to Metformin at all. The latter, however, made a huge impression on my digestion as reported earlier.
My PSA shows another increase to 85 - not in itself a massive rise but in the context of the most expensive drug known to Prostate Cancer patients somebody needs to ask the question I asked before we started on it: When is the cost/benefit for a man of 83 simply not justifiable?
I have been getting reasonable pain control from a careful diet of paracetamol and if the radiotherapy is effective I may not need even that for some months. But I am increasingly tired and glad to have given up some major responsibilities in recent week.
So what is there to complain about? Only the disappointing attitude of the Hearers to submissions on the End-of-Life Choice Bill the other day. The Chair seemed to want to argue with the submitters (on our side, anyway) rather than listen to them. Not a good day for Democracy yesterday.
Friday, June 29, 2018
The Submission 2018
Today 29 June 2018, Bev and I attended the hearing of the Justice Selection Committee of Parliament on the End-of-life Choice Bill. It was a very mixed experience, but, for those who are interested and who missed the live stream, this is the text of my submission.
Introduction
I am David
S Mullan, of Red Beach, retired Methodist Presbyter, 83. I have advanced
prostate cancer. I desperately support this Bill.
1. A Very Personal Issue
Hours after
an unrelated surgery I experienced the most appalling tetany spasms. I felt as
if every muscle between my shoulders and knees was tugging on the edge of the
incision. I could neither move nor cry out.
I duly reported
these agonising episodes to the medical staff but nobody commented.
· If that kind of pain, even in
short spasms while unconscious is what I might expect when this wretched disease
overtakes me, I don’t want it.
· If something like that is what
broadcaster Andrew Denton described of his father’s death, I don’t want it.
My cancer is now compressing my spinal
nerves. It is affecting my legs. I am being medicated for daily pain. I can
expect to be progressively paralysed and eventually made helpless. My
experience with the mysterious tetany spasms leads me to believe that I may be
one of the 15% of Hospice patients whose pain is simply not able to be
palliated.
I had hoped that this Bill might have
become Law in time for me to choose to take an organised farewell of family and
friends and depart this life in some dignity. That now seems unlikely.
I may therefore decide to become another
statistic among older people who are ending our lives prematurely. We are being
treated with disdain by Parliament when all we ask for is some dignity and
choice.
It is ironic to me that the opponents of
the Bill already have their choice. But people like myself who know they are at
risk of a bad death do not have choice for a dignified end. For us, this is an
issue of Human Rights.
I submit that Parliament must
decide that Choice for some citizens should no longer mean No Choice for
others.
2. Religious Issues
As a
Christian thinker, I am troubled that some religious people say that untreated
pain is in itself a transformative experience, is “good for the soul”.
That
kind of religious teaching must be for their
people. To apply this principle to others
in a secular and democratic society is, in my view, disrespectful—and tragically
wrong. So, the
attempts by some submitters to hide the identity of their church are, in my
view, little short of deceitful.
I am a
member of the Methodist Church which has a history of being vocal on social
justice issues. But it has based its views on contemporary and well-considered
theological considerations. And rather than opposing change, it has usually
given a lead to the community in changes for the better. Even in my lifetime it
has taken action on Pacifism, Apartheid, Prison Reform, Industrial Relations,
Homosexual Law Reform and the whole range of gender and Human Rights issues right
up to the acceptance of LGTB people in church leadership.
So I
stand in a tradition which has tried to encourage the wider community to become
more liberal rather than to scold it with antiquated theologies and some
“biblical” principles that were conceived in a different world.
I speak
from the experience of a working lifetime in pastoral care, social work and
ministry formation. I have entered into the suffering of many who have died
badly. I have worked with their pastors and their frustrations. Now I face my
own journey into dark places and I sense that my country does not respect my
need.
And I
speak from the perspective of the Christian Jesus who ministered to the needs
of the marginal people of society. He put their personal needs
ahead of institutional respectability and tradition.
I submit that your
Committee might also sit lightly to institutional religion and give priority to
charity and compassion for all people.
Kia
ora tatou katoa!
Dave
Mullan
28/101 Red Beach Rd, Red
Beachn 0932
+64 9 426 7562 +6421 159 2896
Notes
Although Hon Maggie Barry, as is her wont, made quite a few speeches on her own account, in the guise of asking questions of some submitters, at the end of the my submission, when I paused for questions, her first one was "Would you like a cup of tea?" I wasn't expecting that. I must have made some impact. We then had some discussion about the merits - or otherwise - of the report of the original Committee and properly conducted opinion polls and that was that.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)





